Abstract | 第3-4页 |
摘要 | 第5-7页 |
Dedication | 第7-8页 |
Acknowledgements | 第8-21页 |
List of Abbreviations and Symbols | 第21-23页 |
General Introduction | 第23-32页 |
Part 1 : The Comorian people's right to self-determination | 第32-107页 |
Chapter 1: The colonisation period of the archipelago of Comoros | 第34-54页 |
1.1. The archipelago of Comoros under French protectorate regime | 第35-41页 |
1.1.1. Establishment of the protectorate regime in Comoros | 第36-38页 |
1.1.2. The contestation of the protectorate regime | 第38-41页 |
1.2. The new status of Comoros:the French colony | 第41-47页 |
1.2.1. The annexation Act and its scope | 第42-44页 |
1.2.2. The contestation of the attachment | 第44-47页 |
1.3. The internal autonomy of Comoros:the way to independence | 第47-54页 |
1.3.1. The phase of the administrative and financial autonomy | 第48-50页 |
1.3.2. The framework law of 1956 | 第50页 |
1.3.3. The Internal autonomy of Comoros | 第50-54页 |
Chapter 2: Accession of Comoros into independence | 第54-106页 |
2.1. General view of self-determination | 第55-79页 |
2.1.1. Historical perspective of the right to self-determination | 第55-76页 |
2.1.1.1. Self-determination before the First World War | 第56-59页 |
2.1.1.2. Self-determination after the First World War | 第59-66页 |
2.1.1.3. Self-determination under the international law jargon | 第66-76页 |
2.1.1.3.1. Self-determination under aegis of articles 1 § 2 and 55 of the UNCharter | 第66-68页 |
2.1.1.3.2. The UN General Assembly Resolutions 1514 (XV) and 1541(XV) | 第68-70页 |
2.1.1.3.3. The International Covenants of 1966 | 第70-71页 |
2.1.1.3.4. The Declaration on Friendly Relations | 第71-73页 |
2.1.1.3.5. The African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights | 第73-74页 |
2.1.1.3.6. The Helsinki Final Act | 第74页 |
2.1.1.3.7. The Jurisprudence of the International Court of Justice | 第74-76页 |
2.1.2. Different meanings and forms of self-determination | 第76-79页 |
2.1.2.1. Self-determination: right or principle? | 第76-77页 |
2.1.2.2. Different forms of the right of people to self-determination | 第77-79页 |
2.1.2.2.1. External self-determination | 第77-78页 |
2.1.2.2.2. Internal self-determination | 第78-79页 |
2.2. Comoros' self-determination | 第79-101页 |
2.2.1. The conditions to implement the right to self-determination in Comoros | 第79-87页 |
2.2.1.1. The quality of Comorian people:the subjugated people | 第80-85页 |
2.2.1.2. The colonial domination | 第85-87页 |
2.2.2. The operation of self-determination of Comoros | 第87-96页 |
2.2.2.1. The organisation of referendum of 22 December 1974 | 第88-96页 |
2.2.2.1.1. The political bases of self-determination in Comoros | 第89-91页 |
2.2.2.1.2. The legal basis of self-determination referendum of Comoros | 第91-94页 |
2.2.2.1.3. The popular consultation of 22 December 1974 | 第94-96页 |
2.2.3. The political and legal consequences of the self-determination referendumof 22 December 1974 | 第96-101页 |
2.2.3.1. The failure of the decolonisation process of Comoros caused by the Parliament | 第96-99页 |
2.2.3.2. The unilateral declaration of independence of Comoros | 第99-101页 |
2.3. The recognition of independence of Comoros | 第101-106页 |
2.3.1. The recognition by the ex-colonial power | 第102-103页 |
2.3.2. The recognition by the international community | 第103-106页 |
Conclusion of the first part | 第106-107页 |
Part 2: Mayotte:French Overseas Department or dismemberment of Comoros? | 第107-153页 |
Chapter 3: Does the island of Mayotte have a separated right to self-determination? | 第108-127页 |
3.1. Do wa maore comtitute people other than the people of Comoros? | 第109-114页 |
3.2. Does the population of Mayotte have the right to refuse independence? | 第114-127页 |
3.2.1. There is no right to refuse independence | 第115-120页 |
3.2.2. Mayotte's theses against independence | 第120-127页 |
3.2.2.1. The "realities" of Mayotte's attachment to France | 第120-123页 |
3.2.2.2. The truth about Mayotte's attachment to France | 第123-127页 |
Chapter 4: Scope and limits to the self-determination of Mayotte | 第127-152页 |
4.1. Mayotte's right to self-determination is subject to the territorial integrity of Comoros | 第127-137页 |
4.1.1. The principle of territorial integrity in international law | 第128-133页 |
4.1.2. Wa maore's right to self-determination and the principle of the territorial integrity of Comoros | 第133-137页 |
4.1.2.1. Self-determination of Comoros cannot be plural | 第134-136页 |
4.1.2.2. Self-determination of Comoros involves the preservation of the territorial integrity of the Comorian overseas territory | 第136-137页 |
4.2. The principle of the right of peoples to self-determination does not meansecession | 第137-140页 |
4.3. The prohibition of the secession | 第140-152页 |
4.3.1. The prohibition of secession in international law | 第141-143页 |
4.3.2. The exception of the prohibition: the remedial secession | 第143-148页 |
4.3.2.1. The constitutional right to secession | 第144-145页 |
4.3.2.2. The remedial secession | 第145-148页 |
4.3.3. International practice against secessions:the case of Comoros | 第148-152页 |
Conclusion of the second part | 第152-153页 |
Part 3: France's non-compliance with international law | 第153-202页 |
Chapter 5: The violation by France of the Vienna Convention of the Law of Treaties of 1969 | 第154-176页 |
5.1. Violation of the Vienna Convention of 1969 | 第155-166页 |
5.1.1. The violation of article 26 of the Vienne Convention of 1969 | 第155-161页 |
5.1.1.1. Rule of good faith | 第156-160页 |
5.1.1.2. The violation of the rule of good faith in the Comoros' self-determination process | 第160-161页 |
5.1.2. The violation of article 27 of the Vienne Convention of 1969 | 第161-166页 |
5.2. The questionable position of France enshrined in the decision of 31 December 1975 on the self-determination of Comoros | 第166-176页 |
5.2.1. Determination of the modalities for the implementation of article 53 of the France Constitution of 1958 | 第166-170页 |
5.2.2. The erroneous assertion of respect for international rules | 第170-176页 |
Chapter 6: France's non-compliance with international law | 第176-200页 |
6.1. France's violation of the principle of uti possidetis juris | 第177-185页 |
6.1.1. The meaning of the principle of uti possidetis juris in international law | 第177-182页 |
6.1.2. The principle of uti possidetis juris in the case of Comoros | 第182-185页 |
6.2. Permanent interference in the internal affairs of Comoros by France | 第185-200页 |
6.2.1. The meaning of the principle of uti possidetis juris in international law | 第186-190页 |
6.2.2. Comoros' internal affairs violated by France | 第190-200页 |
6.2.2.1. The mercenary phenomena in Comoros | 第191-193页 |
6.2.2.2. The deportation of President SAID MOHAMED DJOHAR | 第193-197页 |
6.2.2.3. The affair MOHAMED BACAR | 第197-200页 |
Conclusion of the third part | 第200-202页 |
Part 4: The way forward to settle the Franco-Comorian territorial dispute over Mayotte | 第202-240页 |
Chapter 7: Sharing the sovereignty on Mayotte between Comoros and France:the condominium theory | 第204-226页 |
7.1. The concept of condominium in international law | 第205-218页 |
7.1.1. The general meaning of sovereignty in international law | 第205-207页 |
7.1.2. The absolutism State sovereignty and its limits: the limitation of sovereignty and the sharing of sovereignty | 第207-211页 |
7.1.3. Sharing sovereignty, an exceptional notion in international law:the condominium | 第211-218页 |
7.2. Different perspectives of sharing sovereignty and competences | 第218-226页 |
7.2.1. Comorian sovereignty, French administration | 第219-220页 |
7.2.2. One sovereignty, two administrations | 第220-226页 |
Chapter 8: The implication of the United Nations bodies to settle the Franco-Comorian territorial dispute over Mayotte | 第226-238页 |
8.1. Request of an advisory opinion before International Court of Justice | 第227-232页 |
8.2. Seizing the United Nations Security Council | 第232-235页 |
8.3. Forum prorogatum | 第235-238页 |
Conclusion of the fourth part | 第238-240页 |
Part 5: General Conclusion & Recommendations | 第240-247页 |
Chapter 9: Conclusion | 第241-244页 |
Chapter 10: Recommendations | 第244-247页 |
10.1. The Comorian government must have a strong national policy on thisquestion | 第244-245页 |
10.2. Promoting the country's economic development | 第245-246页 |
10.3. France's policy to be improved | 第246-247页 |
Bibliography | 第247-264页 |
Books & theses | 第247-253页 |
Articles & newspaper column | 第253-258页 |
Cited Cases | 第258-260页 |
Treaties,Conventions and Declarations | 第260-261页 |
Security Council Resolutions | 第261页 |
General Assembly Resolutions | 第261-262页 |
Organisation of African Unity and African Union Resolutions | 第262页 |
National Constitutions, Domestic Legislations | 第262-263页 |
Website | 第263-264页 |
Annexe Ⅰ | 第264页 |